As a small, local bakery, we handcraft every custom cake. For this reason, we take a small number of orders and require at least 48 hours notice. Cake orders taken under 48 hours before order date are subject to a 20% rush fee.

PICKUP is available from either of our Manhattan locations: Chapter I – 102 W 73rd ST or Chapter II – 156 E 64th ST

DELIVERY ORDERS: Fees start at $35. Delivery available in Manhattan and certain neighborhoods of Brooklyn only.

Download our full Cake Information PDF by clicking here.

Let’s get started!

First, choose your cake flavor:

  • Vanilla
  • Chocolate
  • Red Velvet
  • Banana*
  • Carrot*
  • Lemon*

Then choose your filling:

  • Vanilla Buttercream
  • Chocolate Buttercream
  • Cream Cheese
  • Strawberry Preserves
  • Raspberry Preserves
  • Caramel Buttercream*
  • Lemon Buttercream*
  • Lemon Curd*
  • Mocha Buttercream*
  • Chocolate Ganache*
  • Chocolate Mousse*
  • Nutella*

Lastly, choose your frosting**:

  • Vanilla Buttercream
  • Chocolate Buttercream
  • Cream Cheese
  • Swiss Buttercream
  • Vanilla Fondant*
  • Chocolate Ganache*

*Any flavor, filling or frosting marked with a (*) is considered premium, and is an additional $15 fee each.
** Most of our in house designs require Vanilla Buttercream; all other frostings may be applied homestyle. Some custom designs may also require Vanilla Buttercream or Vanilla Fondant.

Now that we’ve got that squared away, let’s figure out what size cake you’ll need…

Cake Sizes, Servings

  • 6″ round : feeds up to 6
  • 8″ round : feeds up to 20
  • 10″ round : feeds up to 30
  • 12″ round : feeds up to 40
  • 1/2 sheet : feeds up to 75

In-House | Custom (Base) Price

  • $51 | $80 and up
  • $80 | $117 and up
  • $117 | $170 and up
  • $170 | $255 and up
  • $280 | $420 and up

Last but not least, let’s talk design!

We’ve got six in-house designs we offer, however, we do encourage you to get creative! We can accommodate most custom designs, but ask that you email us an image of what you’re looking for, so that we can let you know if/what we can accommodate, and the exact costing. Take a look at our six in-house designs below:


To submit a request for a cake, please fill out the form below:


Need some inspiration?

Check out more custom cakes we’ve done in the past below!